Technical Shell Suggestion's?

Communicate with fellow Zoners

Moderators: SkiDork, spanky, Bubba

laseranimal
Post Traumatic Stress Syndrome
Posts: 3703
Joined: Dec 19th, '04, 22:29
Location: Center cut or Pin High

Post by laseranimal »

Nikoli wrote:But can a soft shell really stop the wind as well as Gortex. The South Ridge Triple can really be cold especially that last 10 towers.
you're expecting the South Ridge Triple to actually RUN, boy you're optimistic

In practical terms, a soft shell won't stop wind as well as a hard one, BUT if you get the right mix of clothes underneath you'll be fine, its just a question of tuning your insulation properly.

I think you're probably going to wind up going with a hard shell, but definitely take a long look at the new generation of soft shells.
Climb the mountains and get their good tidings. Nature's peace will flow into you as sunshine flows into trees. The winds will blow their own freshness into you, and the storms their energy, while cares will drop off like autumn leaves.

John Muir
b-5
Wanted Poster
Posts: 3480
Joined: Apr 15th, '06, 20:36

Post by b-5 »

laseranimal wrote:
Nikoli wrote:But can a soft shell really stop the wind as well as Gortex. The South Ridge Triple can really be cold especially that last 10 towers.
you're expecting the South Ridge Triple to actually RUN, boy you're optimistic

In practical terms, a soft shell won't stop wind as well as a hard one, BUT if you get the right mix of clothes underneath you'll be fine, its just a question of tuning your insulation properly.

I think you're probably going to wind up going with a hard shell, but definitely take a long look at the new generation of soft shells.
umm i have 2 say that it all depends on what company makes that soft shell.
I have a Phenix soft shell that is Five years old.
it is Water proof(does not wet out).
Wind Proof.
and has so-so at best thermal props.
I chop wood in it.
ride my bike in it.
on cool/cold days i use it mtn biking(does not have the best wicking props, but i will deal with it.
I all so have a moon stone soft shell.
water resisant, so-so wind protection.
i mostly use my soft shells 4 a super warm under layment.

bla-bla-bla.
I also ski in a Scott soft shell.
Wind protection water proof and umm-umm-umm -umm-umm toasty!
Nikoli
Poster Child Poster
Posts: 2101
Joined: Apr 17th, '07, 08:49

Post by Nikoli »

b-5 & laseranimal,
Thanks for all of the info its greatly appricated.

Yes, I am hoping that the SRT will run this year. They have an extra $400 dollars of mine to make it so.


~Nick
johnny the jibber
Level 10K poster
Posts: 11170
Joined: Oct 23rd, '05, 21:08
Location: where the figawi?

Post by johnny the jibber »

everyone should wear camo...patrol will never find ya...

Image
he would shove your ass so far up your ass and stuff! -thejet61 10/2/09

If a snowboarder is in front of me or to the side I assume the slobbering moron will cut from one side of the trail to the other -GSKI 1/17/12
b-5
Wanted Poster
Posts: 3480
Joined: Apr 15th, '06, 20:36

Post by b-5 »

johnny the jibber wrote:everyone should wear camo...patrol will never find ya...

Image
Mossy Oak!
Carvemeister
Beginner On Rentals
Posts: 30
Joined: Nov 13th, '04, 14:08
Location: Shoreham, Long Island
Contact:

Re: Technical Shell Suggestion's?

Post by Carvemeister »

Nikoli wrote:I am in the market for a Men's Technical Shell.

I was wondering if anyone had any recommendations. I ski mostly northeast over 30 days a year.

I was hoping to get something with the following requirements.

1) Helmet Compatible Hood. (Removable would be nice)
2) Snow Skirt.
3) Taped Seams
4) Gortex
5) Under $400

Thanks
~Nick
You need to keep your eye on http://www.steepandcheap.com/ so you can grab deals like this one: http://sac.gearattack.com/items/6652.

I was lucky enough to be there at the right time. A very nice jacket and an insane deal for $120. My Arcteryx is just a slight bit nicer designed than this, but it was four times the price.

Oh my, here's another: http://sac.gearattack.com/items/6925
Good stuff.
Last edited by Carvemeister on Sep 26th, '07, 13:26, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
tyrolean_skier
Signature Poster
Posts: 22337
Joined: Nov 4th, '04, 23:28
Location: LI, NY / Killington, VT

Post by tyrolean_skier »

Stormchaser wrote:Nice jacket, but there ain't no running and hiding from ski patrol in that jacket... sh*t you could be on the peak, and your friends can find you from the parking lot!
Maybe Nikoli does not like to venture off the beaten path. :wink:
Image
Image
User avatar
Stormchaser
Level 10K poster
Posts: 14087
Joined: Nov 4th, '04, 22:32
Location: Hot tub

Post by Stormchaser »

tyrolean_skier wrote:
Stormchaser wrote:Nice jacket, but there ain't no running and hiding from ski patrol in that jacket... sh*t you could be on the peak, and your friends can find you from the parking lot!
Maybe Nikoli does not like to venture off the beaten path. :wink:
He found us...he will soon.
ImageImageImageImage
User avatar
RENO
Whipping Post
Posts: 7985
Joined: Nov 5th, '04, 08:14
Location: Ceti Alpha V

Re: Technical Shell Suggestion's?

Post by RENO »

Carvemeister wrote:
Nikoli wrote:I am in the market for a Men's Technical Shell.

I was wondering if anyone had any recommendations. I ski mostly northeast over 30 days a year.

I was hoping to get something with the following requirements.

1) Helmet Compatible Hood. (Removable would be nice)
2) Snow Skirt.
3) Taped Seams
4) Gortex
5) Under $400

Thanks
~Nick
You need to keep your eye on http://www.steepandcheap.com/ so you can grab deals like this one: http://sac.gearattack.com/items/6652.

I was lucky enough to be there at the right time. A very nice jacket and an insane dea for $120. My Arcteryx is just a slight bit nicer designed than this, but it was four times the price.

Oh my, here's another: http://sac.gearattack.com/items/6925
Good stuff.
Yeah, about 100 jackets a day come up on SAC. Great site. Also check out Sierra Trading Post below. Bought lots of stuff from them over the years.

You don't have to spend anywhere near $400 for a great jacket. For $400 you could get a jacket, pants, underwear, gloves and socks and still have money left over!

http://www.sierratradingpost.com/search ... rchWithin=
KnuckleDragger
Powderhound
Posts: 1645
Joined: Nov 5th, '04, 08:05
Location: CT
Contact:

Post by KnuckleDragger »

laseranimal wrote:
Nikoli wrote:
laseranimal wrote:which means that unless you're out when its pouring BUCKETS you'll never notice the difference(except for the price)
One of the reasons I want to switch to Gortex was last January being r*ined on. My jacket got so wet my cell phone died. However, my current jack is 8 years old.
If its 8 years old the DWR coating has worn off, any new shell gore tex or not would be a huge improvement. You could always try to pick up some NIKWAX and try to restore the waterproofing, but I think 8 years is long enough for a jacket

have you tried a soft shell? Much more comfy/breathable then a hard one but you give up something in the waterproof department. Snow and drizzle you're fine, but a full on drenching is going to be problematic. For BC skiing I'll generally wear a soft shell and toss in a unlined r*in jacket like the Marmot Pre-cip in my pack just in case it gets wet
Nikwax definitely does work for restoring waterproofing. I used it on my pants last year. I'm not sure if it affected the breathability of the material or not but my sittin'-in-the-snow-snowboarder-ass stayed dry.
Image
Carvemeister
Beginner On Rentals
Posts: 30
Joined: Nov 13th, '04, 14:08
Location: Shoreham, Long Island
Contact:

Post by Carvemeister »

KnuckleDragger wrote:[Nikwax definitely does work for restoring waterproofing. I used it on my pants last year. I'm not sure if it affected the breathability of the material or not but my sittin'-in-the-snow-snowboarder-ass stayed dry.

Restoring the waterproof coating via Nikwax will enhance the breathability of Goretex because it prevents the outer layer of fabric from wetting-out, which would in turn prevent water vapor from escaping outward.

Nikwax should probably be re-applied every year or two for best performance.
b-5
Wanted Poster
Posts: 3480
Joined: Apr 15th, '06, 20:36

Post by b-5 »

KnuckleDragger wrote:
laseranimal wrote:
Nikoli wrote:
laseranimal wrote:which means that unless you're out when its pouring BUCKETS you'll never notice the difference(except for the price)
One of the reasons I want to switch to Gortex was last January being r*ined on. My jacket got so wet my cell phone died. However, my current jack is 8 years old.
If its 8 years old the DWR coating has worn off, any new shell gore tex or not would be a huge improvement. You could always try to pick up some NIKWAX and try to restore the waterproofing, but I think 8 years is long enough for a jacket

have you tried a soft shell? Much more comfy/breathable then a hard one but you give up something in the waterproof department. Snow and drizzle you're fine, but a full on drenching is going to be problematic. For BC skiing I'll generally wear a soft shell and toss in a unlined r*in jacket like the Marmot Pre-cip in my pack just in case it gets wet
Nikwax definitely does work for restoring waterproofing. I used it on my pants last year. I'm not sure if it affected the breathability of the material or not but my sittin'-in-the-snow-snowboarder-ass stayed dry.
The best way is to start off with nik wash, then follow it with nik wax.. Reg detergent will still shorten the life of nik wax.
and it will wet out sooner.
there is some other stuff(comes in a blue bottle) that works as well if not better.
I am just 2 lazy to venture down 2 the basement to check out the name...
boston_e
Wanted Poster
Posts: 3018
Joined: May 19th, '07, 21:12

Post by boston_e »

Nikoli wrote:But can a soft shell really stop the wind as well as Gortex. The South Ridge Triple can really be cold especially that last 10 towers.
I love my soft shell (Marmot). When I got it I was expecting to just wear it on warmer days, but I find that even on the colder days I'm about 50/50 on going with the soft shell or the other.

My other jacket is a Mountian Hardware which I love too.
Nikoli
Poster Child Poster
Posts: 2101
Joined: Apr 17th, '07, 08:49

Post by Nikoli »

First I would like to thank everyone for their input.

I think I am going to go the Nikwax way for the time being. I will also be keeping my eye on www.steepandcheep.com.

Thanks Again
~Nick
KnuckleDragger
Powderhound
Posts: 1645
Joined: Nov 5th, '04, 08:05
Location: CT
Contact:

Post by KnuckleDragger »

FYI the stuff I used was the Nikwax TX Direct Spray On stuff. As far as washing the garment first, I just ran the pant through the washing machine with nothing but water.
Image
Post Reply