laseranimal wrote:Nikoli wrote:But can a soft shell really stop the wind as well as Gortex. The South Ridge Triple can really be cold especially that last 10 towers.
you're expecting the South Ridge Triple to actually RUN, boy you're optimistic
In practical terms, a soft shell won't stop wind as well as a hard one, BUT if you get the right mix of clothes underneath you'll be fine, its just a question of tuning your insulation properly.
I think you're probably going to wind up going with a hard shell, but definitely take a long look at the new generation of soft shells.
umm i have 2 say that it all depends on what company makes that soft shell.
I have a Phenix soft shell that is Five years old.
it is Water proof(does not wet out).
Wind Proof.
and has so-so at best thermal props.
I chop wood in it.
ride my bike in it.
on cool/cold days i use it mtn biking(does not have the best wicking props, but i will deal with it.
I all so have a moon stone soft shell.
water resisant, so-so wind protection.
i mostly use my soft shells 4 a super warm under layment.
bla-bla-bla.
I also ski in a Scott soft shell.
Wind protection water proof and umm-umm-umm -umm-umm toasty!