yeti wrote:
As one senator put it: "we just spent $20,000,000 to fly six people from Florida to New Mexico when United will do it for $5K.... and throw in some peanuts."
that might be the dumbest thing i've ever heard. no wonder a politician said it.
(Feel free to move this thread at anytime to politics)
Is it? There really isn't anything that the shuttle has done that could not have been done cheaper - not to mention SAFER - using more traditional vehicles (or better yet unmanned ones). And I am talking 70's era Saturn boosters. (A system BTW, that we no longer have the ability to replicate even if tomorrow W jumped up and ordered us to build one. How lame is that?)
Looking at it from the politico's view point: hand him a spread sheet showing a return on investment. Or even a return at a loss. You said yourself they travel in relative comfort - and they don't stay up very long so no real life sciences are accomplished. Experiments and observations can be automated and sent up much cheaper. Fix the Hubble? So the guys have to wear psuits, piss in a tube, and don't get to hang out in shirtsleeves... it could have been done for a fraction of the cost.
Hey don't get me wrong I am all for manned exploration: I devoted well over half of my life in an attempt to go myself while 99% of the population who cares is content to merely dream about it. But looking at things through a clear lens of objectivity I can firmly say that the goal is worthy but the means lacking. It was a good trick in the 80's, but by now we should have airliners, or at the very least military vehicles - that can out perform the shuttle at a fraction of the cost.
But we don't have those things, in part because the cumbersome and expensive shuttle was always in place and good enough. Damn a computer geek (albeit a very weathly one) hired a guy to design and build him his own rocket plane (along with the jet that launched it).... and the goddamn thing worked! They did this for under half of what it costs in fuel alone to launch the shuttle once.
I wish the crew well - I really do - and I wish they had a ship worthy of their talents and expertise!
[/i]